Determination of Critical Control Points

FSQMS Guide

A critical control point (CCP) is a process step at which control is essential to prevent or eliminate a significant food-safety hazard or reduce it to an acceptable level. Determining CCPs connects the hazard analysis with the limits, monitoring and response used to keep production under control. The decision concerns a specified hazard, product and process route; an equipment name or a preferred number of CCPs cannot establish it.

The multidisciplinary Hazard Analysis and Critical Control Point (HACCP) team is responsible for assessing the available measures and deciding where essential control must operate. Its assessment should record those decisions, explain reliance on prerequisite programmes or other non-CCP measures and identify gaps requiring product or process redesign. A justified designation, a control ready for use and evidence of successful production are separate results.

Determining and maintaining critical control points

CCP determination establishes, with supporting evidence, where essential controls are needed for the hazards addressed by the HACCP plan. Reviewing and updating those decisions keeps the CCP designations current. Initial plan development, scheduled review, proposed change and new evidence can initiate an assessment. The team leader should define the question to resolve, the products and decisions affected, who needs to contribute and when the result is needed. Keep current production under the plan in force while proposed revisions are assessed, unless the evidence requires immediate protection or restriction.

The number and location of CCPs follow the actual hazard-control assessment. A low count is not an improvement objective, and a high count does not establish comprehensive control.

The intended result is a complete set of reasoned decisions for the hazards requiring control, covering the applicable process routes and operating conditions. Decisions to designate a CCP identify the step and its hazard-control relationship. Decisions not to designate a CCP explain the effective alternative and its conditions. Unresolved decisions identify the missing evidence and responsible owner. They remain open until the evidence supports a conclusion.

Preparing the assessment and evidence

The HACCP team leader should establish the products, routes and operating conditions to examine, the method to use and the evidence needed. Identify who will contribute, who holds technical decision and document-approval responsibilities, and who will cover absences. Management is responsible for providing time to obtain evidence, observe the process, resolve questions and check the outcome. Establish review and change-notification routes so decisions remain current after the initial exercise.

The team leader or appointed coordinator should obtain the current hazard analysis, product descriptions, intended-use information and confirmed flow diagrams. Trace each hazard requiring control to its proposed measures and acceptable level. Check that relevant rework, outsourced steps, seasonal routes and variations are included. Compare document versions with the actual operation and resolve missing or inconsistent inputs before relying on them. A material gap may require revision of the product description, confirmation of the process flow or renewed hazard analysis.

Use stable process-step references that agree with the flow diagram. Associate each assessment with the relevant product or justified product group, formulation/specification version and process route. If products grouped together do not share the same hazards, control capability or routing, separate their assessment or describe the differences explicitly. A common line number alone does not justify a common decision.

Allocate time for collecting and checking inputs, visiting relevant operations, applying the determination method, resolving questions, recording reasons and reviewing the result. Include different shifts or seasonal conditions where they affect the evidence. Compare this workload with the team's available time after ordinary duties and absence cover. If the decision must precede a launch or process change, plan backwards from that date and resolve an infeasible timetable through resources, scope of the proposed change or delay of introduction.

If an ingredient specification changes the expected hazard condition or a flow correction exposes a bypass, return that information to the originating analysis and identify the decisions potentially affected. Retain an identified owner to obtain the revised input and coordinate any protection needed for current work. A corrected diagram alone does not establish that all dependent control decisions have been reconsidered.

For supplier or outsourced control, establish who performs the measure, which products it covers and what capability and performance evidence is available. Clarify changes and exceptions the provider must report and when. A later customer or consumer activity cannot be assumed to provide the necessary control without a justified intended-use assessment. Claims about an external control require an actual, dependable arrangement rather than a general expectation.

The preceding work on hazard analysis and control measures establishes which hazards require control and the measures proposed. Use process flow verification to resolve whether the assessed routes correspond to actual operation. Resolve material gaps in those inputs before relying on the affected CCP judgement.

Establishing competence and assigning decision authority

Responsibility for defining the review scope, obtaining current evidence, arranging participation and maintaining the decision record rests with the HACCP team leader or appointed coordinator. Team members contribute their expertise to the assessment of hazards and controls. Operations personnel explain actual routes and working conditions; engineering personnel establish relevant equipment capability and failure behaviour; technical specialists assess hazards, control evidence and acceptable levels. Include procurement or the external provider where supplier controls or outsourced steps affect the decision.

The team remains responsible for its technical determination. A coordinator who compiles answers does not thereby make every decision. Senior management cannot resolve a scientific uncertainty merely by accepting a commercial risk, and an external adviser does not acquire authority over the site's daily operation unless that responsibility is explicitly assigned. Retain enough understanding within the site to implement advice and recognise when its conditions no longer apply.

Select participants with competence in the actual question. General HACCP training is useful but does not establish specialist knowledge of every thermal, chemical, microbiological or engineering mechanism. Ask members to explain the evidence supporting a consequential decision and how process variation could change it. Obtain specialist advice when the team cannot judge the control's capability or the acceptable level of the hazard.

Give the reviewer access to the underlying information and the ability to require clarification or further work. For a consequential or contested determination, competent challenge by another qualified person, group support or an external specialist can improve reliability. A different job title alone does not establish effective challenge. Record disagreement and the technical question requiring resolution rather than allowing a vote or schedule pressure to conceal it.

CCP classification and the resulting design requirements are the HACCP team's responsibility. Plan approval and issue rest with the people authorised under document control. Acceptance of validation evidence belongs to designated technical personnel, confirmation of operating readiness to operations, and funding or production-restriction decisions to the authorised manager. Decisions about affected product remain with the designated product-disposition authority. One person may hold several responsibilities, but evidence of one approval cannot establish all of them.

Assign cover for coordination, technical interpretation and urgent operating decisions. Before planned absence, transfer current assessments, unresolved evidence, review dates and interim arrangements. The deputy is responsible for confirming that they understand the transferred work, are competent to undertake it, can access the necessary information and hold the authority needed for the decisions involved. If no competent decision-maker is available, escalate to the nominated alternative and restrict work that depends on an unsupported decision. On return, reconcile decisions and outstanding work before responsibility transfers back.

When specialist support is needed, define the exact question, products, process conditions and date the advice is required. The internal recipient is responsible for comparing the advice and its limitations with the site's conditions, obtaining any clarification needed and bringing supported advice into the team's decision. This retains access to expertise without substituting a generic report for the site's assessment.

Understanding the hazard and the control mechanism

A control measure is the action or condition that prevents or eliminates a hazard or reduces it to an acceptable level. The process step is where that measure acts. Equipment may enable the measure, and an observation or measurement may indicate its performance; neither automatically constitutes a separate CCP. Identify these relationships before applying the determination method.

A biological control may prevent growth, inactivate an organism or prevent its introduction. These effects are different. A step that controls vegetative bacteria does not necessarily control spores or toxins; a step that prevents multiplication does not establish that an initially excessive contamination level has been reduced. The HACCP team should identify the organism, toxin or other harmful agent, how it could reach or affect the product, and the result needed. Compare the proposed control's demonstrated effect with that required result.

Chemical and physical hazards also require specific mechanisms. A detector's response to a particular contaminant depends on the material, size, orientation, product and equipment conditions tested. Detecting an item contributes to control only where the affected product is reliably removed or otherwise prevented from release. A thermal step cannot be assumed to remove an undeclared allergen or a metal fragment. Evidence about one mechanism cannot justify an unrelated hazard-control claim.

The acceptable hazard level is a food-safety outcome. A critical limit is the measurable or observable condition used to distinguish control status at a CCP. The two can use different quantities. Process temperature and exposure time can be used to control a biological hazard where validation establishes their relationship to the required effect. Measuring a convenient parameter without that relationship produces an operating reading whose safety interpretation is unsupported.

Compliance personnel identify the legal limits and duties applicable to the product and market, with technical specialists establishing how they affect the assessment. Customer agreements and external assurance conditions can require particular evidence or review intervals. Record the applicable condition and who is responsible for keeping that information current. An internal target cannot authorise a hazard level prohibited by an applicable obligation. Where the basis is unclear, obtain competent interpretation before accepting the affected conclusion.

A risk score may help the preceding significance assessment, but it does not locate the essential process control. The HACCP team still needs to explain the measure's effect, the result required and what would happen if control were lost. Establish the basis of the acceptable hazard level before deciding whether a measure can achieve it.

Applying a consistent determination method

The team should retain the chosen tool and edition and record the reasons behind its answers. A decision tree is a reasoning aid. It does not require the business to accept a result inconsistent with the technical evidence. Resolve that inconsistency by examining the question, scope and evidence, consulting a specialist where needed and documenting the supported decision. Do not combine questions from different tools without establishing the resulting method and its meaning.

Use the selected method consistently across the relevant hazard–step relationships. Begin with a named significant hazard, the step and product route being examined, the proposed measure and the hazard outcome required. Review the full route so an answer about one step does not conceal an uncontrolled hazard elsewhere. The following sequence organises that reasoning; it requires technical evidence for the particular operation.

First, establish whether a prerequisite programme or another non-CCP measure adequately controls the specific hazard under the stated conditions. Identify the actual method and supporting capability evidence. Where that conclusion is supported, record the arrangement and its implementation and verification needs. Where it is unsupported, continue examining the specific process controls.

Next, identify measures that act on the hazard at the candidate step and elsewhere in the route. Establish whether control at the candidate step is essential by examining the consequence of its loss, the capability of any later measure and the contributions of combined measures. Apply the later-step comparison and combined-measure assessment below to those particular questions. A process step without an applicable measure cannot supply the missing control simply by being labelled a CCP.

Then record the conclusion supported by the evidence. Designate the step as a CCP where control there is essential to prevent or eliminate the hazard or reduce it to an acceptable level. Record a decision not to designate the step as a CCP where another adequate arrangement is demonstrated, naming that arrangement and its conditions. If the process has no effective measure where safety requires control, begin redesign to provide the missing control. If the evidence cannot establish which conclusion is justified, retain an unresolved decision and assign the further inquiry. Do not treat uncertainty as a reason to record that the step need not be a CCP.

Finally, reconcile the decisions across the whole process. Trace every hazard requiring control to an adequate arrangement, including every product route concerned. Check that any decision not to designate a CCP in reliance on another step refers to a real, assessed control and that essential combined contributions remain visible. Resolve missing links before accepting the determination as complete.

Assessing prerequisite and other non-CCP controls

Prerequisite programmes establish and maintain the conditions needed for safe production. Where a specific hazard is assigned to one of these programmes or another non-CCP measure, the team needs evidence that it adequately controls that hazard under the stated conditions. A general cleaning procedure, supplier certificate or training record alone does not establish the required effect. Identify the particular method, its capability and the checks showing it remains in use.

Prerequisite programmes remain independently managed controls. Where a programme controls a specific hazard, identify the relevant method and validation in the plan. A label such as operational prerequisite programme must be interpreted under the site's adopted system and cannot substitute for identifying the measure, criteria, monitoring and response. Review the actual protection provided before accepting the classification.

The HACCP team should compare the programme's scope, operating method and evidence with the specific hazard, products and conditions assessed. Identify who maintains the programme, what monitoring and response preserve its required effect, and how its results will inform HACCP review. Record those controls in the plan. The prerequisite-programme guidance develops their establishment and continuing management.

Testing reliance on a later step

When a later step is proposed as the reason an earlier step need not be a CCP, the HACCP team should identify the exact later step and the condition of the hazard that could reach it if the earlier measure failed. Compare that condition with the later control's validation: the harmful agent covered, starting level, product properties, process conditions and required result. Examine every relevant route, including bypasses, rework and products diverted to another line. A later control can support the decision only for the products that actually pass through it under the conditions its evidence covers.

An earlier holding control may remain essential if its loss permits toxin formation that the later treatment has not been shown to address. Alternatively, where the later step can achieve the necessary control across the justified incoming conditions, that step can provide the decisive control and the earlier point may remain managed through another arrangement. Record the supported reasoning and its boundaries. If the comparison cannot establish the later step's capability, obtain suitable technical evidence or reassess the control design; an untested assumption does not justify deciding against designation of the earlier step as a CCP.

Assessing essential combined measures

Some control systems depend on more than one step. Examine each measure's contribution and the combined effect. Where two steps are both essential to bring the same significant hazard under control, both need consideration as CCPs. A later essential contribution does not automatically make the earlier contribution dispensable. Equally, several checks of the same working measure do not necessarily create several CCPs. Distinguish the control step from observations used to monitor or verify it.

Do not add the claimed performance of separate measures without evidence that their effects combine under the actual conditions. Product composition or processing history can change the performance of a later measure. Measures can also share a dependency: the same incorrect formulation information, failed utility or mistaken route selection can undermine several apparent barriers together. Assess those shared conditions when deciding whether another measure provides effective control after failure of the first.

One CCP may control several hazards, but each hazard-control claim needs a supported mechanism and suitable criteria. Conversely, one hazard may need several CCPs with distinct contributions. Preserve those relationships in the assessment and plan rather than assigning every hazard to one generic control row.

Resolving uncertainty and obtaining timely decisions

When the team disagrees, state the precise technical question and compare evidence against the same product, hazard, route and conditions. Differences can arise from different assumptions about rework, failure consequences or the capability of a later step. Correct the underlying information where the evidence establishes an error. Obtain specialist advice where the team cannot establish the mechanism or required result. Retain the unresolved issue and current operating response until someone competent can reach a supported conclusion.

A zero-CCP outcome requires deliberate re-examination of scope, significance decisions and the evidence for all alternative controls. It can be justified only where the actual hazard-control arrangement supports it and applicable requirements are met. Finding no CCP does not establish that the business has no hazards. Equally, adding unnecessary designations to reach an expected count can make the plan less usable without providing the missing control.

Escalate when a required technical judgement exceeds the team's competence, evidence conflicts materially, a control cannot be implemented, or resources and authority cannot be obtained in time. When escalating, identify the affected products and decisions, supporting facts, uncertainty, present controls, consequence of delay and the specific expertise, resource or decision needed. Contact the authorised technical specialist or senior manager according to that need and confirm receipt when timing affects control.

Keep a named owner responsible for following the issue until an authorised recipient has accepted responsibility and the agreed response has been implemented. If the recipient is unavailable, use the deputy or next authority. Maintain justified restrictions or product protection while the matter remains unresolved. Placing the item on a future agenda does not provide a timely decision for current production.

Recording decisions and preserving their history

For each hazard requiring control, identify the product or justified product group, process route and step reference, hazard and acceptable-level basis, proposed measures, conclusion and reasons. Name the prerequisite or other non-CCP measure, later control or combined measures on which the decision depends. Identify supporting evidence precisely enough to retrieve the relevant report, section and version, including assumptions limiting its application.

Where a decision aid is used, retain its version and record the reasons behind answers. Where expert judgement supplies the method, identify the relevant expertise and reasoning. A sequence of unexplained yes/no answers or a signed table containing only CCP numbers cannot establish the underlying judgement. Keep missing evidence and consequential disagreement visible until resolved.

Record participants, assessment date, technical agreement and the approvals required by the site's document and change processes. The record should show which version of the hazard analysis and flow diagram was considered. Preserve decisions not to designate a CCP as well as decisions to designate one: a future reviewer needs to know why an apparently important step was not designated and what condition would change that conclusion.

A determination can be proposed, awaiting evidence, technically agreed, incorporated into the approved plan, effective in operation or superseded. The site can use different labels while preserving these distinctions. Record the effective date and the products or production periods to which each approved version applies. A future proposal must not silently replace the controls governing current production.

When reclassifying a control, preserve the earlier decision alongside the reason for change, new evidence and approval. Do not reuse an obsolete CCP reference for an unrelated control in a way that makes historic records ambiguous. Keep a cross-reference where renumbering is necessary. Preserve the traceability of product made under the earlier arrangement to the plan and records that applied to it.

Create the assessment record during the work and distinguish original facts from later interpretations. Check references and document versions before issuing it. Correct errors through a method retaining the original entry, author, date and reason. Protect approval status and access rights, back up electronic records and test that authorised users can retrieve the complete decision history.

Set retention from applicable legal, customer and assurance requirements and the continuing purpose of the evidence. Preserve older determinations and capability evidence for the products, records and unresolved matters that still depend on them. Identify any required retention starting event; do not delete support merely because the current template or plan version changed.

Give participants access to the current determination and its underlying evidence while restricting confidential supplier or commercial material to authorised users. Before changing systems or providers, transfer the relevant evidence and access rights and test retrieval. If the normal system becomes unavailable, use a controlled alternative that preserves decisions, authorship, status and history, then reconcile temporary records when service returns.

Putting designated controls into operation

The HACCP team is responsible for providing the people developing critical limits and validation with the agreed step, hazard, products, required control outcome and assumptions about capability. Those recipients need to establish how the proposed criteria relate to the required control of the hazard. The people responsible for monitoring design then specify what to observe, where, when and how, who is responsible, and what record is needed to establish compliance with those criteria. Assess whether information is available in time for the required response and how affected production will be identified if a gap is found.

Operations and engineering confirm feasibility before the plan is treated as ready. A monitoring gap calls for further design work; it does not justify ignoring an essential step. Define how corrective action will restore process control and address product made while control was lost, including the response to a trend towards loss of control. Verification examines implementation and continuing operation. Ask the receiving teams to confirm the work they have undertaken and identify any prerequisites still outstanding.

Issue the approved version and remove obsolete operating copies through document control. Use training and supervision to establish that affected personnel can apply the revised method and respond to abnormal results. Management is responsible for supplying resources and resolving priority conflicts while preserving the team's technical judgement and the designated authority for product-status decisions.

Validate each CCP and its critical limits before relying on the revised arrangement. Use measurable criteria wherever possible. Where a critical limit depends on subjective assessment, provide clear instructions or examples so personnel apply it consistently. For discontinuous monitoring, establish how samples will represent the applicable product batch rather than merely selecting the most convenient unit.

Record the measurement date, time and result, and the signature of the person responsible for CCP monitoring, using the site's accepted paper or electronic method. Where verification is appropriate, a suitably competent and authorised person verifies the records. For electronic records, retain evidence of checking and verification. These downstream records do not prove that the original determination of CCPs was complete, but they can expose assumptions needing reassessment.

The coordinator is responsible for tracking these handovers and obtaining confirmation of completed work or details of missing prerequisites from the receiving teams. Before the revised plan takes effect, compare its limits, monitoring location, records and response instructions with the agreed determination and validation. Check equipment readiness, competent cover and usable instructions across the intended operating pattern. Record the effective date and withdraw obsolete operating copies. A difficulty establishing reliable monitoring returns to design and technical assessment; it does not remove the essential-control need.

Maintain personnel competence, instrument calibration, equipment maintenance and access to current technical evidence after introduction. Reassess dependent controls before a resource or provider is withdrawn. More detail on the next design task is available in the guidance on establishing critical limits for CCPs.

Checking decisions and reviewing continuing suitability

A competent reviewer should start from the current hazard analysis and actual process scope, then trace each hazard requiring control to its determination. Examine decisions to designate a CCP, decisions not to do so and open questions. Compare step references with the confirmed flow and check relevant alternate routes, rework and outsourced operations. Investigate a missing or mismatched route before judging the plan complete.

For a decision not to designate a CCP, retrieve the actual evidence for prerequisite, other non-CCP or later-step control and compare its conditions with the product and hazard assessed. For combined controls, examine each essential contribution and the evidence supporting the combination. For a designation, establish why the control is essential and whether a practicable validated control arrangement follows. Read the reasons and underlying evidence. The number of completed worksheet cells does not show whether the decisions are justified.

Use challenge questions that can expose an invalid assumption: what changes if the earlier measure fails, if rework follows a different route or if the incoming hazard condition falls outside the conditions supported by the later control's evidence? Answer from evidence and technical reasoning. Do not perform unsafe production experiments to test a failure. Where new trials are needed, competent specialists design controlled work with clear restrictions on trial materials and product.

After approval, compare the effective HACCP plan, monitoring instructions and actual work with the agreed determination. Observe the relevant location and product route, discuss duties and abnormal-result response with operators, and retrieve monitoring and verification records. Check that the control is applied to the products and conditions the decision covers and that obsolete instructions are no longer used.

Choose records and observations that reflect relevant differences in the operation: different routes, products, shifts, start-up, changeovers or seasonal conditions where they affect the conclusion. State what was examined and why. A targeted high-risk sample can reveal a serious weakness but does not establish its prevalence across all work. Additional representative evidence is needed for a broader performance claim.

Monitoring results show particular observations against criteria. They depend on suitable methods, sampling, instruments, timing and reliable records. Examine missing or late entries, deviations, failed checks and response delays alongside favourable results.

Validation supports the proposition that a control can achieve the specified result under defined conditions. A monitoring record describes an observation at a particular time or production interval. Verification records show what implementation or operating checks were performed and their findings. A favourable audit, absence of complaints or a small set of negative product tests has limited scope and cannot replace missing evidence of capability.

At planned review, compare current products, hazards, methods and operating range with the original decision basis. Examine validation, monitoring, deviations, verification, complaints, incidents, new knowledge and relevant changes. Determine whether the issue concerns analysis, design, execution or the ability to interpret evidence. Assign further inquiry where the conclusion remains uncertain.

Where customer or external assurance arrangements require annual review of the plan and prerequisite programmes, complete it at least annually, with earlier review before relevant change and when evidence challenges safety. Record why a decision remains suitable or what must change, who will act and how the result will be assessed. Communicate significant findings to the team and resource needs to management. Keep responsibility for technical assessment and operating follow-up assigned after reporting the findings.

Improve sound arrangements as well as correcting failures. Better route identification, clearer rationale, more representative validation or simpler access to evidence can strengthen decision reliability. Define the weakness or intended improvement, change the method or resource that affects it and examine subsequent use. A reduction in CCP numbers or reported deviations is not, by itself, evidence of improvement.

Keep review of the actual HACCP decisions distinct from maintenance of the document describing how review is performed. A longer procedure-review interval cannot defer an applicable annual plan review or assessment before a food-safety-relevant change. When replacing or retiring a CCP, retain its effective period and decision history. Transfer outstanding actions, required records and continuing responsibilities when a product or line leaves the plan scope.

Report significant system findings and resource needs to management review. Responsibility for CCP determination and assessment of current product remains with the designated functions. Where a formal corrective-action case follows, link it to the original finding and retain the respective closure decisions. Share transferable findings with owners of comparable processes without assuming the same CCP classification applies everywhere.

Assessing change and responding to a discovered weakness

Product or process owners are responsible for notifying the HACCP team before changes to formulations, ingredients, suppliers, packaging, intended use, equipment, operating speeds, routes, rework, utilities or outsourced steps that may affect food safety. The team compares the proposed changes with the assumptions and evidence supporting current determinations. Identify changed hazard conditions, altered capability or monitoring, new routes and dependencies on other measures.

Update the information and assumptions about the product and process, and revise the hazard analysis, before accepting the revised designation. Validate the affected plan before implementing a change that may affect product safety. Before factory introduction, complete the revised limits, monitoring and response arrangements and instructions, establish the necessary personnel competence and obtain the required food-safety approval. Where old and new arrangements coexist, identify the products and production periods governed by each so operators and reviewers use the correct plan.

Changing a CCP to a non-CCP requires evidence of adequate alternative control, its implementation and the reason the original essential-control judgement no longer applies. Removing a difficult record or reducing workload is not that evidence. Adding a CCP also needs complete design and operating arrangements; a new designation cannot resolve an existing capability gap.

If a hazard was omitted, a route bypasses an essential control or the control cannot achieve its claimed effect, identify the affected products, production period and current operation as far as evidence permits. The authorised operational team restricts unsafe work, identifies and holds potentially affected product, and obtains a competent assessment of its disposition. Where product has left control, activate the appropriate incident, withdrawal or recall assessment without waiting for the next HACCP review.

Preserve the original records and distinguish observations from assumptions about cause. The HACCP team examines how the weakness affects the hazard analysis, control capability and earlier CCP reasoning. Review comparable products or routes sharing the same assumption. Missing records or uncertain timing require a justified assessment of the potentially affected scope rather than a convenient declaration that only the last batch was involved.

An isolated monitoring deviation does not automatically require a new CCP classification. Apply the defined process and product response, investigate its meaning and determine whether the design remains sound. Repeated deviation, evidence of an omitted hazard or inability to maintain the control can require wider reassessment and redesign. Maintain both paths when current product action and design investigation are necessary.

Where reassessment identifies an actual capability gap, use the redesign and temporary-control arrangements below. Where it identifies a failure in applying an otherwise capable control, apply the process/product response and corrective work appropriate to that finding. Maintain a named owner and communicate current instructions while the team resolves the technical conclusion.

Providing an effective control when the existing process cannot

Redesign provides a control measure where a significant hazard needs control and the existing product or process cannot achieve the required result. The gap may be found during initial determination, review, a proposed change or investigation of evidence from operations. The business remains accountable for effective control. Delivery of the remedy is led by process development, with engineering, technical, operations and supplier contributions suited to the change. Responsibility for hazard assessment and CCP designation remains with the HACCP team, and resource, operating and product decisions remain with the designated managers.

Defining the gap and the required remedy

Record the control gap by stating what control is missing, the products and routes affected, the result required, current restrictions, who owns the remedial work and what further decision is needed. Identify the selected remedy, alternatives considered, technical basis, resources and acceptance criteria in the resulting design. Link trials, installation, validation, training and readiness evidence to that same change so a reviewer can distinguish planned work from delivered capability.

Translate the gap into a technical requirement before selecting equipment or a formulation change. Where control is necessary for safety at a step but no measure exists, modify the product or process at that step or an earlier stage to provide the required control when it is needed. State the hazard outcome required, products and operating range covered, assumptions, applicable duties and the evidence needed for acceptance. Identify how the measure will be monitored, what response will protect product and which current restrictions remain necessary. The person responsible for delivering the remedy confirms that they accept the assignment, can access the relevant information and can obtain the decisions and resources needed.

Assessing options and providing the means to implement them

The development owner and HACCP team compare product and process options against the required control of the hazard, operating range, monitoring feasibility, new hazards and implementation needs. Funding and priorities are management decisions within those technical conditions. Options can include changing formulation, adding or changing a process step, altering the route or discontinuing the affected operation if adequate control cannot be provided. Availability of a cheaper option does not establish its capability.

The development owner explains what the remedy must achieve and when the current gap could affect safety. Establish required technical performance, product/process range, monitoring and response capability, installation access, utility needs and continuing support. Engineering and operations assess whether the design can be maintained and used at the expected throughput and under relevant operating variation. Technical specialists establish the validation needed and the capability required to carry out the tests.

When planning resources, allow for design and specialist time, trials, equipment, procurement lead time, production access, installation, commissioning, instruments, training, record changes and verification after introduction. Identify shared constraints, such as one engineer or a short shutdown needed by several actions. Assess the combined schedule rather than approving dates independently when they cannot all be met.

Expenditure approval rests with management within its remit. After approval, the development owner confirms delivery of the purchased equipment or service, and the receiving team assesses its suitability for the intended work. Equipment arrival does not establish installation, technical acceptance or operating readiness. Record outstanding dependencies and escalate them before they compromise the control requirement or an authorised restriction.

Technical specialists compare each option's control mechanism with the required control of the hazard. Examine new hazards, changed barriers and interactions across the process rather than assessing the new equipment alone. A design that cannot be monitored or reliably operated needs further development before the site relies on it.

Protecting product and controlling temporary operation

Identify the products, production period and current work potentially affected by the gap. The authorised operational team establishes operating restrictions, holds potentially affected product and obtains competent product assessment; where product has left control, activate the appropriate incident assessment. The design action can proceed while that work continues, and its eventual completion does not determine the status of product already made.

Before using a temporary alternative, define the products, method, conditions, owner, evidence of capability, monitoring, product response and authority. Set its duration or ending event and review triggers. Obtain technical and operational approval within the site's change arrangements. A temporary designation or promised future equipment does not waive a required safety condition. Where a capable alternative cannot be established, restrict or suspend the affected work.

The manager authorised to approve temporary use examines the capability evidence and confirms that the personnel, monitoring, records and authority to respond are available to apply the method. Review actual performance within its authorised scope and reassess before any extension. Keep the original gap and remedy due date visible so temporary operation does not become the unexamined permanent arrangement.

Implementing, validating and approving the changed arrangement

Implement the selected remedy through controlled development and change. Plan trials and validation with competent specialists, identifying the conditions and outputs required. Control trial materials and product status so carrying out an experimental operation is not mistaken for permission to release food. Validation of the affected plan precedes reliance on the changed arrangement.

Repeat the affected hazard analysis and CCP determination using the revised product/process facts. Complete critical limits, monitoring, process and product response, verification and instructions for the selected controls. Compare implementation records and actual installation or formulation with the approved requirement and capability evidence. Resolve differences in the product range, throughput, utilities, operating conditions or monitoring method before accepting readiness.

Before factory introduction of a new product or changes to formulation, packaging or processing methods, obtain formal approval by the HACCP team leader or an authorised HACCP team member under the site's change arrangements. Confirm hazard assessment, implemented controls and validation of the affected plan before use. Management approval of resources within its remit does not replace technical acceptance, operating readiness or the separate disposition of existing product.

Identify the manager authorised to permit restart and the evidence required for that operating decision. Confirm current instructions, competent personnel, available equipment and monitoring and response capability. Record the effective date, affected products and any continuing limitation. Where old and new arrangements coexist, distinguish their products and records. Withdraw temporary instructions when their accepted replacement takes effect and transfer remaining work to an identified owner.

Verifying performance and closing the redesign action

After introduction, compare evidence from representative operation with the criteria set for the change. Confirm that the new measure makes its required contribution to control and that operators adopt the required method under the relevant workload. Where sustained performance needs further operating experience, keep responsibility for follow-up assigned and state the limited conclusion already supported. A failed result returns to investigation or redesign with current-product protection as needed.

Close the design action through the authorised decision based on evidence that the remedy meets its criteria. Retain the separate decisions on incident closure, affected-product disposition and closure of an originating finding, as applicable. Apply what has been learned to comparable processes, development standards and team competence. The improvement is sustained when later products and changes use the revised knowledge and resources, rather than merely when the original action is marked complete.

Retain unsuccessful trials and changes in assumptions with the final evidence. If a return to an earlier arrangement is proposed, assess its suitability under current materials, equipment and use conditions before authorising it. Product or process facts may have changed since the earlier arrangement was used.

In the closure record, connect the original gap with the delivered remedy, revised hazard analysis and determinations, capability evidence, implementation checks, approvals and operating findings. State any later evidence still required, its owner and review date. Continue monitoring and review after closing the design action, using the control arrangement in force and preserving the history needed to interpret future changes.

Stay connected with Food Industry Hub

Receive Food Industry Hub updates, resources and practical content for food manufacturing businesses and professionals.

Stay informed about new resources, articles, tools and Food Industry Hub service developments.

Raise the standard for how food gets made.