Know: Audits (Internal and External)

Sector-Specific Information

The Food Industry Hub knowledge centre delivers a wide range of sector-specific information for food industry professionals.

The below is one topic from our knowledge centre. You can return to all topics by clicking here.

Audits (Internal and External)

Definition

Audits are structured evaluations of a food manufacturing business’s operations, processes, and documentation to ensure compliance with food safety, quality, and regulatory standards.

Internal audits are conducted by personnel within the organisation, typically independent of the area being assessed, while external audits are carried out by third-party certification bodies, customers, or regulatory agencies.

Audits serve multiple purposes, including verifying the effectiveness of food safety management systems, ensuring compliance with legal and regulatory obligations, identifying areas for improvement, and driving continual operational enhancements.

Practical Application

1. Internal Audits
   Internal audits form an integral part of a Food Safety Management System (FSMS), providing a self-assessment mechanism to ensure compliance and preparedness for external evaluations. These audits follow a structured process:
• Preparation: Develop a detailed audit plan outlining the scope, criteria, and schedule.
• Execution: Review processes, inspect records, and interview employees to evaluate compliance.
• Reporting: Document findings, highlighting non-conformances and opportunities for improvement.
• Corrective Actions: Address identified issues through documented resolutions to achieve sustained compliance.
2. External Audits
   External audits verify compliance with specific standards or requirements. Outcomes often include certifications, approvals, or penalties, depending on findings. Types of external audits include:
• Third-Party Certification Audits: Conducted by certification bodies to assess adherence to standards such as BRCGS, FSSC 22000, or ISO 22000.
• Customer Audits: Performed by buyers or retailers to ensure suppliers meet their contractual food safety and quality expectations.
• Regulatory Inspections: Conducted by government agencies to confirm compliance with laws, such as the FDA’s FSMA requirements in the U.S. or EU food safety regulations throughout Europe.
3. Key Tools and Techniques
   Effective audits rely on a combination of tools and methodologies, including:
• Checklists and Standards: Align audit activities with recognised frameworks such as HACCP, GMPs, and established procedures.
• Non-Conformance Reporting: Document deviations and assess their root causes.
• Sampling and Testing: Use analytical methods to verify product safety and quality.
• Follow-Up Audits: Evaluate the implementation and effectiveness of corrective actions.

Related Concepts

Audits intersect with several critical elements of food safety and quality management:

• Audit Scope and Frequency: Defining the activities to be reviewed and determining the intervals based on risk assessments.
• Non-Conformance Management: Systematically addressing and resolving issues identified during audits.
• Continuous Improvement: Leveraging audit findings to enhance operational processes and prevent recurrence of issues.
• Certification Standards: Frameworks such as BRCGS, SQF, and FSSC 22000 that provide criteria for external audits.
• Compliance Documentation: Maintaining comprehensive records of policies, procedures, and monitoring logs to demonstrate conformity.
• Supplier Audits: Evaluating suppliers to ensure the safety and integrity of raw materials.

Expert Insights

1. The Role of Internal Audits
   Internal audits are invaluable for identifying risks and addressing them proactively, reducing the likelihood of non-conformances during external audits. They foster a culture of self-assessment and continual improvement.
2. Preparation is Paramount
   Audit success depends on thorough preparation—up-to-date documentation, trained employees, and adherence to practical and procedural standards are all essential.
3. Challenges in External Audits
   External audits can feel high-pressure due to their implications for certification or compliance. Approaching them as collaborative opportunities for improvement, rather than adversarial exercises, can improve outcomes.
4. Emerging Trends in Auditing
   The shift toward remote audits during the COVID-19 pandemic underscored the importance of digital documentation and robust communication tools in facilitating efficient evaluations.

Challenges and Best Practices

1. Common Challenges
• Inadequate documentation or records leading to non-conformance findings.
• Employee resistance to audits, often stemming from a perception that they are punitive.
• Misalignment between internal audit practices and external audit expectations.
2. Best Practices for Effective Audits
• Audit Readiness: Foster a mindset where every day is “audit day” by embedding compliance into routine operations.
• Employee Training: Ensure staff are confident in explaining processes and responding to auditor questions.
• Mock Audits: Simulate external audits to identify weaknesses and improve preparedness.
• Root Cause Analysis: Use findings to conduct deep investigations into underlying issues, driving meaningful corrective actions.

Conclusion

Audits are indispensable for maintaining food safety, ensuring regulatory compliance, and driving continual improvement in the food manufacturing sector. Internal audits provide a foundation for self-assessment and readiness, while external audits validate adherence to industry standards and build trust with customers and regulatory authorities.

By embracing audits as opportunities for growth and aligning operations with recognised frameworks, businesses can strengthen food safety systems, enhance brand reputation, and achieve operational excellence. Far from being a mere requirement, effective auditing is a strategic advantage in the pursuit of long-term success.

About The Food Industry Hub Knowledge Centre

The Food Industry Hub knowledge centre delivers informative content on a variety of topics pertinent to the food manufacturing industry.