Know: Label Claims and Regulatory Compliance

Sector-Specific Information

The Food Industry Hub knowledge centre delivers a wide range of sector-specific information for food industry professionals.

The below is one topic from our knowledge centre. You can return to all topics by clicking here.

Label Claims and Regulatory Compliance

Definition

Label claims in the food industry refer to the information and statements presented on product packaging that describe the attributes, benefits, or qualities of the food item. These claims may include nutritional facts, health benefits, processing methods, origin, and ingredient-specific details. Regulatory compliance ensures that such claims meet legal requirements set by governing bodies such as the UK’s Food Standards Agency (FSA), the European Food Safety Authority (EFSA), and similar organisations internationally. Proper adherence to regulations ensures consumer trust, legal protection, and market access.

Practical Application

1. Types of Label Claims
• Nutritional Claims: Statements such as “low fat,” “high in fibre,” or “source of protein” are regulated with specific nutritional thresholds.
• Health Claims: Assertions about the relationship between a food and health, such as “reduces cholesterol” or “boosts immunity,” require scientific substantiation and regulatory approval.
• Ingredient Claims: Labels like “organic,” “non-GMO,” or “100% natural” must adhere to standards defined by regulators.
• Origin and Ethical Claims: Statements like “Made in Britain,” “Fair Trade Certified,” or “locally sourced” must be verifiable and accurate.
• Free-From Claims: Terms such as “gluten-free” require the product to meet strict thresholds for allergen presence.
2. Regulatory Framework
• In the UK and EU, claims are governed by Regulation (EC) No. 1924/2006 for nutrition and health claims. These regulations standardise permissible claims and prohibit misleading statements.
• Country-specific standards: For international trade, understanding local regulations is essential. For instance, the US FDA has distinct rules for label claims compared to UK or EU standards.
• Claims must comply with general food labelling laws, including the Food Information to Consumers (FIC) Regulation (EU) 1169/2011, which requires clear, unambiguous, and substantiated statements.
3. Compliance Process
• Substantiation: Health and nutritional claims must be backed by robust scientific evidence, often involving clinical trials or peer-reviewed studies.
• Label Review: Internal or third-party reviw ensure that all claims meet regulatory standards before market release.
• Certification: For claims like “organic,” obtain certification from an accredited body such as the Soil Association (UK).
• Continuous Monitoring: Regular reviews are essential as regulations and scientific consensus evolve.
4. Challenges in Label Claims
• Scientific Complexity: Providing evidence for health claims often involves complex and costly studies.
• Cross-Border Regulations: A claim valid in one jurisdiction may not comply with another, necessitating label variations for export markets.
• Consumer Misinterpretation: Even accurate claims can be misunderstood by consumers, leading to potential reputational risks.

Related Concepts

• Traceability: Ensures the accuracy of claims related to origin or sourcing, such as “locally sourced” or “sustainably harvested.”
• Food Labelling Standards: Governed by overarching regulations to ensure clarity, legibility, and non-deceptiveness in claims.
• Allergen Labelling: Related to “free-from” claims, this requires strict adherence to allergen declaration rules.
• Marketing and Branding: Label claims are critical in communicating a brand’s value proposition to consumers.

Expert Insights

1. The Role of Transparency
• Transparency is key in building consumer trust. Misleading or unsubstantiated claims can lead to significant legal penalties and damage to brand reputation.
• Providing accessible information on how claims are substantiated, such as via QR codes linking to evidence, can further enhance credibility.
2. Balancing Marketing with Compliance
• While label claims can be a powerful marketing tool, they should never compromise technical validity. Overstating a product’s benefits or using vague terms like “superfood” without evidence can invite regulatory scrutiny.
• Simple, clear, and verifiable claims resonate more effectively with consumers.
3. Staying Ahead of Regulatory Changes
• Monitoring changes in food labelling regulations is critical, especially for businesses operating in multiple jurisdictions. For example, updates to EU health claim approvals or UK-specific post-Brexit changes may impact labelling requirements.
4. Consumer Education
• Educating consumers about the meaning of claims, such as the specific criteria for “low sugar” or “high fibre,” can mitigate misunderstandings and enhance brand loyalty.

Conclusion

Label claims play a vital role in the food industry by communicating a product’s quality, benefits, and distinctiveness. However, ensuring regulatory compliance is paramount to avoid legal risks and maintain consumer trust. By substantiating claims with solid evidence, adhering to jurisdiction-specific regulations, and prioritising transparency, food manufacturers can effectively leverage label claims as a competitive advantage. For businesses, a proactive approach to monitoring regulatory updates and market trends ensures long-term success and compliance in a dynamic industry landscape.

About The Food Industry Hub Knowledge Centre

The Food Industry Hub knowledge centre delivers informative content on a variety of topics pertinent to the food manufacturing industry.